Watermaster, Well Metering Orders on New Mexico’s Middle Rio Grande

The New Mexico Office of State Engineer Friday posted its long-awaited “metering orders,” the first step toward an enhanced regulatory framework to get our arms around who is using water, and how much, along New Mexico’s Middle Rio Grande.

One of the orders formally creates a “water master”:

The District Water Master shall have immediate charge of the apportionment of waters in the District under the general supervision of the State Engineer, and shall appropriate, regulate, and control the waters of the District so as to prevent impairment to senior water right owners and to prevent waste.

The second order also requires metering of groundwater wells. Sort of. Big municipal wells are already metered and regulated. The order would apply to other wells, such as agricultural wells, golf courses, industry (some of those are already metered). Importantly, it does not apply to existing domestic wells, arguably the largest currently unmeasured and therefore unregulated draws on the system:

1. Well owners are required to install totalizing flow meters, on all new and existing groundwater wells within the District in accordance with the standards set out in this Order, with the following exceptions:

a. Existing single wells on a parcel serving solely domestic uses of a single household, including the irrigation of one acre or less of noncommercial trees, lawn, or garden;

b. Existing wells used solely for watering livestock in a grazing operation.

2. The Water Master will require a meter for any well that is not required to have a meter but is deemed likely to have water use exceeding its authorized amount as evidenced by irrigation exceeding one acre, a pond of any size, or activities on site that may result in diversions in excess of authorized amounts.

“1” means new domestic wells all get metered. “2” opens the door for requiring meters on wells irrigating big lots (lots of those in the middle valley!) and ponds, and in general wells that seem to be diverting more than the 1 (for newer domestic wells) or 3 (for older ones) acre feet. Based on our OpenET work, there are likely to be a large number of lots worth triggering “2” for, though structuring the order this ways places the burden on the state to go to each of these thousands of well operators one at a time rather than just placing the burden on all well users to install a meter.

There is a telling allocation of obligation here. The order as written, “deemed likely,” requires an affirmative action by the state, rather than requiring an affirmative action on the part of the water user. This lets little users off the hook for the expense of a meter and reporting, while placing the burden on the state to act in regard to the big users. My hypothesis is that this will result in slow or no action on the many, many big lots on the valley floor that are operating in this legal gray area.

Ponds might be an interesting place to start. They’re pretty obvious.

2 Comments

  1. Is New Mexico a rule of capture state like Arizona? Owners of high-capacity wells will view this as the camel’s nose under the tent, but don’t owners of high-capacity wells have a right to pump as much as they want? Is there any possibility of restricting pumping using laws regarding mineral rights or an idea I have not heard mentioned–EMINENT DOMAIN?

  2. As usual, you are spot on in your analysis.

    I do see some issues:

    “The District Water Master shall have immediate charge of the apportionment of waters in the District under the general supervision of the State Engineer…”

    The term ‘general supervision’ loosely implies that State Engineer is letting the District Water Masters run their own show as they see fit. That equates to no two Districts running by the same exact standards or differences in equipment used. I’m thinking how the data gets reported and how to verify that data?

    When the decision gets passed on down from the State, there should be standards on equipment used, measurement intervals and data reporting standards. Without that, there is no consistency with the end results.

    If left up to the local Districts, the results will be non consistent.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *