Outliers in Nature

A great comment from James Annan on the meta-issues about yesterday’s Nature paper on the possibility that the thermohaline circulation may be slowing: Their(Nature’s) deliberate policy to select only the most “exciting” results, which are then picked up and amplified by the press, pretty much guarantees that the outliers are given a prominence that substantially …

Continue reading ‘Outliers in Nature’ »

Winners and Losers

More on global warming winners and losers: For regions producing high-quality grapes at the margins of their climatic limits, these results suggest that future climate change will exceed a climatic threshold such that the ripening of balanced fruit required for existing varieties and wine styles will become progressively more difficult. In other regions, historical and …

Continue reading ‘Winners and Losers’ »

More on Globally Averaged Surface Temperature

This whole blog-to-blog comment conversation thing can get a bit maddening. What we really need is to all sit down in a room together. I think a lot of the misunderstandings that turn into arguments would instead play out as useful conversations. Plus we could drink beer*. Today’s disjointed conversation has Mark Hadfield raising good …

Continue reading ‘More on Globally Averaged Surface Temperature’ »

Another Vote Against Average Global Temperature – Sorta

Down near the end of a long and ultimately tedious* comment thread over on Prometheus, Gavin Schmidt offered an incredibly useful little gem today. As I’ve written before, “paleoclimate and future projections on a regional scale are critical.” This is one of the reasons I’ve been so interested in the argument Roger Pielke Sr. makes …

Continue reading ‘Another Vote Against Average Global Temperature – Sorta’ »

Stuck in the Middle, Attacked by Both Sides

An amusing comment today from Roger Pielke Jr. about his experience as ringmaster of an on line debate over the relevance of the hockey stick climate reconstruction, placing himself squarely between warring tribes as he tried (with some success, I thought) to spark a useful discussion. I found it amusing to find myself being attacked …

Continue reading ‘Stuck in the Middle, Attacked by Both Sides’ »